Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
The Mayflower
Welcome to The Mayflower, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of the Historic District of Provincetown, Massachusetts. Located at 300 Commercial Street, this establishment promises a delightful dining experience that captures the essence of the East Coast's vibrant food scene.
As you step into The Mayflower, you are welcomed by a warm atmosphere that exudes charm and elegance. The decor strikes a balance between upscale sophistication and coastal comfort, making it the perfect spot for both locals and tourists looking to savor authentic flavors.
From the moment you arrive, the attentive service sets the tone for an unforgettable meal. Customers have praised the staff for their kindness and efficiency, ensuring that every guest feels valued. Take, for instance, the glowing review from Stephanie Frois, who relished her dining experience, remarking on the excellent service and the diverse menu that left every member of her group satisfied.
Speaking of the menu, The Mayflower offers an array of tantalizing dishes that showcase fresh, local seafood, as well as comforting classics with a unique twist. Jon Lynch appreciates the upscale take on local favorites, which adds a refreshing spin to beloved East Coast cuisine. The standout items include:
- Stuffed Baked Cod: A must-try for seafood lovers, featuring delicate flavors that highlight the freshness of the chef's ingredients.
- Lobster Tacos: An innovative dish that marries traditional and contemporary techniques, leaving each patron in awe.
- Lobster Rangoons: These crispy delights have become a favorite, delighting diners with their rich, creamy filling.
- Apple Crisp: A highlight from Leyla M who declared it the best she has ever had—this dessert is perfect for those with a sweet tooth.
The drinks at The Mayflower are equally commendable. Guests rave about the well-crafted cocktails that not only pack a flavorful punch but also enhance the overall dining experience. B Fisher expressed his surprise at the prompt service, offering strong drinks alongside equally impressive appetizers.
After dining at The Mayflower, it’s easy to see why patrons are eager to return. Whether you are visiting for a special occasion or just a casual dinner with friends, the combination of remarkable food, inviting atmosphere, and exceptional service makes this restaurant a top choice in Provincetown. Don’t just take my word for it—make a reservation and indulge in a culinary journey that will surely leave you longing for your next visit!
For reservations, call +1 508-487-0121 and prepare to embark on an unforgettable food adventure at The Mayflower.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ This was our first time there. Our server was very nice and very attentive to us. The food was really great. We all had something different and we all loved our meals. We will definitely go there next year when we go back. ”
“ Atmosphere was great, staff were extremely kind, and the food was incredible!! 100% coming back every time I visit Ptown! (Get the apple crisp, best I've ever had!) ”
“ What a great place. We had no reservations and there were four of us. We had immediate seating right at 5 PM on a Saturday. We had drinks and appetizers and I'm shocked how quickly everything was served. Very friendly and the food was very good. It was also very comfortable and the alcohol drinks were nicely strong and flavored well. Can strongly recommend and will visit again when back in town. ”
“ Everything, from the food and service, was excellent. Ordered the stuffed baked cod, lobster tacos, and lobster rangoons. The rangoons were a favorite of the table! ”
“ Very nice place with an upscale twist on your local East Coast dishes. Friendly service. Nicely decorated place right off the main strip downtown. Fresh seafood and filling dishes are here. ”
“ Food was excellent, period. My son’s burger got a perfectly cooked beef patty, medium rare. The lobster, clams, and shrimps were cooked just right. Highly recommend you to give it a try as they have a big diversified menu! ”
“ Stopped by for lunch between 11:30 and 12. Perfect time. Crowd began to gather shortly after. Wanted something different from seafood. Ordered a Classic Reuben that comes with French fries and, of course a dill pickle. Yum. All the food was exceptional. Perfect Reuben and the fries were so good, no ketchup required. ”
“ Got the twin lobsters and had a blast taking them apart. I probably could have drank the butter and the steamers were also worth the price. 5/5 would go there again. ”